Contact us

(+1) 757 229 0800

Send us an email!

Contact details:

Message:

Your message has been sent successfully. Close this notice.

Travel insurance Quote

Level of protection: $

Contact details:

Travel

Your Quote Form has been sent successfully. Close this notice.

Car insurance Quote

Contact details:

Your car:

Your Quote Form has been sent successfully. Close this notice.

Life insurance Quote

Level of protection: $

Contact details:

Have you used tobacco or nicotine products in the last 12 months?

Yes, I have No, I haven't
Your Quote Form has been sent successfully. Close this notice.

House insurance Quote

Your house:

Contact details:

Your Quote Form has been sent successfully. Close this notice.
Insurance agency

Life insurances
for your family

Insurances do matter

Insurance agency

Insurances

Our Staff Is Here To Help You!!

Insurance agency

Insurance

We Protect You From Theft!!

Insurances do matter

We Protect you from injury!!

Insurance do matter

Benschoten & Carter Insurance Agency now carries Progressive Insurance!

We a Benschoten & Carter have been helping the Williamsburg community and surrounding areas with their insurance needs for over 60 years.

Thank you, we'll call you soon. Close this notice.

Get an insurance quote!

Auto Insurance

Theft Coverage on an Auto Insurance

Get an insurance quote!

Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners Insurance

Get an insurance quote!

Affordable Healthcare Act

Health Insurance

  • Auto Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Affordable Healthcare Act

About us

Meet our insurance agency.

1960s

One of the most respected and enduring companies in Williamsburg Benschoten & Carter is one of the most respected and enduring independent insurance agencies in Williamsburg. The owners, Lee Carter and Cathy Carter Huff, were both raised in Williamsburg and each has more than 20 years of insurance experience. Their fathers, James (Jim) D. Carter III & John (Jack) R. Carter, had been with the agency.

2016

At Benschoten & Carter we not only commit to being the best insurance agent for you but we commit to being productive citizens in our community.

Lee Carter- Owner CIC
Cathy Carter Huff - Owner CIC

Serving you for over 60 years

Best insurances for everyone.

At Benschoten & Carter we not only commit to being the best insurance agent for you but we commit to being productive citizens in our community.

Lee Carter, Cathy Carter Huff
1294 satisfied customers
5 professional agents
8 insurances in our offer
12 years of experience
Take care of your health

Insurances for
your health

Ask a Benefit Advisor if an HSA plan would work for you.

Company informations

Insurance Agency
Lee Carter- Owner CIC
Cathy Carter Huff - Owner CIC

645 Penniman Road
Williamsburg
Virginia 23185, USA

Contact details

E-mail address:
cathy@carter-ins.com

(+1) (757) 229 0800
Fax: (+1) (757) 220 9049

Available 9:00am - 5:00pm